I expected the crude, crass, hilarious dialogue and situations. What
surprised me was the sweetness and the knockout performances: not only
from Jay Baruchel, whose comic personality is unique — but breakout
turns as well from T.J. Miller (the next Jonah Hill), Nate Torrence
(the movie's literal soft center), and “Worst Week”s Kyle Bornheimer,
who deserves to be a star. Plus, Alice Eve has the beauty of a young
Nicole Kidman. SHE'S OUT OF MY LEAGUE is essentially The 25 Year Old
Virgin, but if you don't laugh out loud, you're dead to me. — Jeff
Schultz